GEOFF'S MOVIE REVIEWS - New Reviews

(07.26) Lady in the Water 4.0 / 5
(05.21) Da Vinci Code, The 2.5 / 5
(05.06) United 93 5.0 / 5
(02.05) King Kong 3.5 / 5
(01.29) Syriana 4.0 / 5
(01.24) Walk the Line 4.0 / 5
(01.05) Chronicles of Narnia, The: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe 3.0 / 5
(01.02) Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire 3.5 / 5
(12.30) Jarhead 3.5 / 5
(12.27) Wallace & Gromit in The Curse of the Were-Rabbit 3.5 / 5

New Comments

(12.05) randy: Polar Express, The
(12.02) Geoff: Polar Express, The
(07.27) Jen: Lady in the Water
(07.27) Justin: Lady in the Water
(07.12) Sarah: Da Vinci Code, The
(05.25) Chris: Da Vinci Code, The
(05.25) Acceler8: Da Vinci Code, The
(05.21) Mr Plow: Da Vinci Code, The
(05.11) Sarah: United 93
(05.11) Bread: United 93

Movie Reviews


Village, The

4.0 / 5
Posted by Geoff on Monday, August 23, 2004 at 05:12PM | Post a Comment

I have a huge amount of respect for M. Night Shyamalan. In fact, I took a course on Alfred Hitchcock last year at school, and in my final paper (on which I received an 'A') I compared Shyamalan very favourably to Hitchcock, the film-world's undisputed "master of suspense". So, I certainly had very high hopes for Shyamalan's latest suspense-thriller: The Village.

For the most part, I was very pleased with what he delivered. The Village is a smart, suspenseful, funny, well acted, and beautifully filmed movie, that also happens to be quite thought-provoking long after the credits have rolled. I can't stress that 'beautifully filmed' part enough. Shyamalan has an incredible track record when it comes to making good-looking films, and for The Village he takes that a step further by teaming up with Roger Deakins, one of the industry's most revered cinematographers (whose resume includes such great-looking films as Fargo, The Shawshank Redemption, The Man Who Wasn't There, and A Beautiful Mind).

There is something of a 'twist' near the end of the film, which seems to be a trait of Shyamalan's. I'm not sure if 'twist' is the correct word for it, however, as what occurs near the end of the film is more of a 'reveal' of certain plot elements that are essential to the film and add greater meaning to it overall -- unlike some 'twists' that offer little more than a superfluous "Surprise!" at the end of a film. The 'reveal' in The Village is smartly handled and quite thought-provoking.

If I have one complaint about the film it would be a complaint directed more towards Shyamalan himself. He has proven beyond a doubt to me that he is one of the greatest modern-day filmmakers; yet he seems to be writing himself into something of a corner. I fear that his films are going to become known solely for their 'twists', as I couldn't help but wait for what I imagined to be an inevitable twist to occur in The Village (and not surprisingly, it did). I really hope that Shyamalan tries something a little different with his next project -- maybe a straight drama or (I think this could actually work) a comedy -- to show everyone what else he is capable of, and to avoid being stereotyped as "that guy who does the surprise endings".

Comments: 5

#1 - Posted by Speaks on August 24, 2004 11:07 AM:

I will agree completely that this is one of the better movies I have seen this year. Even better than Napolean Dynamite, sorry Rye. For anyone heading to see it I recommend: DO NOT GO IN EXPECTING ANYTHING! I had heard mixed reviews from people, and everyone who didn't like the movie told me it wasn't what they expected.

#2 - Posted by SuperCoolMonkeyNinja on August 25, 2004 1:13 AM:

I saw this today...I thought it was really good...and I hated all of other M. Night Shamamaghamahekala whatever his name is...

Hey do u know that Night isnt even part of his real name? He actually made that title up for himself...The guy is a dork..or a Wanker...

But still this movie was the best of his so far I would say...but thats not saying much seeing as the other 3 licked more balls then Punk Rock...


TOODLES

#3 - Posted by Bread on August 26, 2004 2:51 AM:

The sixth sense was great, although it was ruined for me, I think I liked Unbreakable even better because I wasn't expecting that either... Signs, I thought was his weakest, and this one was pretty darn good. So its a toss up between Unbreakable and sixth sense.

#4 - Posted by Geoff on August 31, 2004 4:27 PM:

People who ruin movies like The Sixth Sense for other people should be shot.
Anyway, Sarah is definitely right: don't go into The Village thinking you know what it's about. Those who I've heard didn't like the movie always seem to say "it wasn't what I expected" (though I don't see why even that should be a reason for not liking something...).
Rye: Signs is actually my favourite of M.N.S.'s films, with Unbreakable a close second.

#5 - Posted by Chris on January 23, 2005 3:48 PM:

I yelled at the TV, "Turn down the suck!" Holy broing movie batman.

Post a Comment

Remember info?